28 Groups Demand Facebook Stop Intimidating WhatsApp Users.
Facebook is “pestering” WhatsApp users to accept a new policy that allows the social media company to collect more data, while gradually removing key features of the app for those who don’t, a coalition of 28 groups say.
A coalition of 28 groups across the globe May 14 sent a letter to Facebook demanding the company stop intimidating WhatsApp users to accept extended data collection, originally set to take effect on May 15.
Facebook, which bought WhatsApp for $19 billion, is telling users they must let Facebook share personal data or lose access to messages on their account. #TheDefender https://t.co/iTsHHEJSuA
— Robert F. Kennedy Jr (@RobertKennedyJr) May 10, 2021
“Facebook’s prospective business model relies on extended data integration between WhatsApp and Facebook to benefit its own bottom line at the expense of user privacy. Facebook appears dedicated to continuing exploiting WhatsApp data to advance its marketing and commercial interests. Facebook has shown time and again that it simply cannot be trusted to safeguard our privacy or data,” the letter reads.
“We must try to make sure Facebook is in possession of less of our data, not more. We simply cannot let the globe’s messaging service function as Mark Zuckerberg’s latest data goldmine. Given that Facebook’s business model predicated on privacy invasion and consumer exploitation, Facebook never should have been allowed to acquire WhatsApp. The time to break up Facebook has come. The time to act is now. Save WhatsApp!”
Burcu Kilic, digital rights program director, Public Citizen (U.S)
“Terms of usage constantly change to use business models that capitalize on member data with little regard to user privacy. We must ensure that communities, many of whom are Latino, are not held hostage by Facebook. The threat of being dropped from WhatsApp for not accepting privacy changes that only serve Facebook is reprehensible and shameful!”
Jose M. Vargas, executive director, Labor Council for Latin American Advancement (U.S.)
“Facebook continues to aggressively undermine the privacy rights of people using its platforms, including WhatsApp. To squeeze further monetization from WhatsApp, it’s working to rewire this essential global messaging service to further incorporate Facebook’s myriad of extensive commercial data-gathering practices. Facebook’s priorities of placing its constant search for greater revenues over the interest of the public is one reason why the company must be tightly regulated, and WhatsApp must be restored as an independent entity.”
Jeff Chester, executive director, Center for Digital Democracy (U.S.)
“Facebook has repeatedly broken the privacy promises it made when it acquired WhatsApp. It’s time that privacy regulators worldwide stop Facebook from misusing WhatsApp user data.”
Caitriona Fitzgerald, deputy director, Electronic Privacy Information Center (U.S.)
“Facebook’s continuing insistence on exploiting all the people who aren’t protected by privacy laws like GDPR (General Data Protection Regulation) shows how tone deaf this big tech monopoly still is in this crucial moment of reckoning. From all sides, people are demanding that their privacy rights be valued more than big tech profits.
“That Facebook would betray its own promises from when it acquired WhatsApp and continue to push forward in its cruel plan to manipulate and exploit people who are reliant on WhatsApp says a lot not only about the company’s promises, but the company’s prevailing motivations. Let the way that the WhatsApp community is being treated serve as a warning sign that Facebook has not learned and is not changing. In fact, with this move they’re doubling down on abusive surveillance capitalist practices while gaslighting their customers.”
Lia Holland, campaigns & communications director, Fight for the Future (U.S.)
María Paz Canales, executive director, Derechos Digitales (Latin America)
“It is the newer people joining WhatsApp that brings all the value that the network holds. Zuckerberg cannot be allowed to break his promise and still retain WhatsApp.
Regulators across the world must see to it. There has been some good news from Germany in this regard, and we are sure more will follow, with citizen groups keeping up the pressure. The recent announcement that the coercive action on WhatsApp users will be administered slowly over a few weeks and not suddenly is a cruel joke, akin to telling a condemned prisoner that he will not be beheaded but killed by slow strangulation.”
Parminder Jeet Singh, executive director, IT for Change (India)
“WhatsApp and Facebook, in a clear abuse of dominant position, share users’ personal data without legal basis, without clear purposes, and without any possibility of opposition by its users. It’s essential that the companies start respecting consumers’ liberty of choice and right to self-determination by giving them granular options to determine what and how data will be collected, with what purpose and by whom.”
Juliana Oms, attorney, Brazilian Institute for Consumer Protection (IDEC) (Brazil)
“Facebook is adopting a double-standard: good behavior in countries with data-protection laws, and trying to get away with abusive data practices everywhere else, such as this ‘open-time frame’ for accepting the new policy. The fact that executives are bragging that most users have already accepted an abusive policy is alarming. It is time to be the company you claim to be and stop abusing your economic power.”
Flora Rebello Arduini, senior campaigner, SumOfUs (Brazil)
“For too many people, leaving WhatsApp — especially when so many rely on it to keep in touch with their loved ones — is not a viable option. Facebook knows this, yet the company still wants to force users to accept a policy that would undermine their privacy. This is a blatant abuse of their dominance.
“Already South Africa’s information regulator has sounded the alarm about the new policy contravening the country’s Protection of Personal Information Act and how the new policy is discriminatory as people in some parts of the world would enjoy significantly more privacy protections than users elsewhere. Mark Zuckerberg ignoring this call would be a blatant undermining of people’s privacy in the interest of profit.”
Palesa Ramolefo, campaigner, mobi (South Africa)
“We are worried about the instability to which users in Paraguay and the global south in general are subjected to when it comes to privacy policies and terms of services that are constantly changing. It is not fair, particularly when so many individuals don’t have a choice but to use WhatsApp due to poor connectivity and infrastructure.”
Eduardo Carrillo, human rights and public policies analyst, TEDIC (Paraguay)